I tried the NY Special at the El Cerrito location for a team hangout and it delivered big time. Even with all the toppings, the pie baked evenly, the crust stayed crisp, and the cheese pulled like a commercial. The sauce had that balanced herb kick I always hope for. Ordering ahead was easy, pickup was on time, and the staff double-checked our order without being asked. Everyone left happy, with leftovers for lunch.

As someone who keeps halal, I appreciate how clearly the El Cerrito menu lets me build a paneer tikka masala pizza without compromising. The creamy garlic base, tender paneer, and fresh cilantro made every slice pop. The heat was gentle, not overwhelming. We ate in the El Cerrito Plaza area park nearby and the pizza held up beautifully—still crisp and hot. Friendly counter service and fair pricing sealed the deal.

The pesto chicken pizza was the surprise favorite at our movie night. The pesto tasted bright and fresh, the tomatoes and mushrooms were generous, and the bacon bits added a nice smoky snap. The crust was crunchy at the edge and chewy inside, exactly how we like it. We ordered online from El Cerrito, got a precise ready-time, and pickup took under a minute. Simple, fast, and seriously good.

Create Your Own is my go-to. I picked mozzarella, pepperoni, jalapeños, and olives on an extra-large, and it came out perfectly balanced—not greasy, not skimpy. The team in El Cerrito gave great topping advice and suggested chipotle sauce, which turned out amazing. Slices reheated well the next day. Between the quality and the consistency, it’s become our default Friday treat. Buy Pizza Online really is as convenient as promised.

We ordered two calzones—one cheese-only for the kids and one combo for the grownups. Both were packed, golden, and sturdy enough to share without falling apart. The marinara on the side tasted like it simmered, not poured from a jar. Staff at the El Cerrito shop labeled everything clearly, which helped when we set up dinner buffet-style. Great value for a family meal, with zero hassle.

Wings night did not disappoint. We split Buffalo, Garlic Parmesan, and Mango Habanero, and each flavor was distinct. The Buffalo had a real tang, the garlic parm was rich without being heavy, and the mango habanero brought sweet heat that crept up nicely. The eight-piece portions were just right, and the texture was crisp outside and juicy inside. Pickup at El Cerrito was quick and the packaging kept everything tidy.

I’m a salad person and the Greek salad here is honestly excellent. The feta is crumbly and clean-tasting, the Kalamata olives are legit, and the veggies are crisp. I added chicken and chose balsamic, which didn’t drown the greens. It’s a dependable lunch in El Cerrito when I want something lighter with my slice. Friendly service, spotless counters, and consistent portions keep me coming back weekly.

For our birthday crowd we went big with a Super King Kong and a stack of slices so late arrivals had options. The giant pie was a showstopper—easy to feed everyone and still tasted great cold. Slices moved quickly for kids between activities. Prices were fair for the size, and timing was on point. The El Cerrito team managed the rush calmly and kept us smiling the whole time.